Tumultuous first year for Germany's government may start energy transition push
When Germany鈥檚 鈥渢raffic light coalition鈥 took office in early December 2021, it promised to make energy and climate policy central to its work. The three-party coalition under chancellor Olaf Scholz vowed to deliver a new style of government after 16 years of Angela Merkel鈥檚 leadership by making climate and energy a thread that runs through all of their policies; from healthcare to finances to foreign policy. One year later, energy policy indeed has been at the heart of the German government鈥檚 agenda 鈥 although under vastly different circumstances than it had initially hoped for.
Russia鈥檚 attack on Ukraine聽that was launched soon after the government's inauguration on 8 December last year and the ensuing energy crisis in Europe sent the traffic light coalition -- named after the party colours of 厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 Social Democrats (SPD), the Green Party and the Free Democrats (FDP) -- through a baptism of fire. The crisis made some of the goals of the coalition treaty difficult to achieve, but greatly accelerated the progress of others. While many observers initially deemed the government鈥檚 reaction , it ultimately took a big step towards readjusting the country's energy policy and sped up the process of cutting the vast direct dependence on Russian energy.
The 鈥溾 watershed moment Scholz announced just days after Russia launched its invasion attempt inevitably came with substantial political costs for the new government. On the one hand, it had to prepare voters and businesses which had just emerged from two years of the pandemic for another nationwide crisis due to skyrocketing energy prices threatening the country鈥檚 industrial core and social cohesion. On the other hand, Germany鈥檚 standing among its European neighbours was shaken as the country -- despite many and repeated warnings by its allies against deepening ties through the unused Nord Stream 2 pipeline -- found itself exposed and vulnerable to Russia鈥檚 weaponising of energy assets, thereby weakening the EU鈥檚 position as a whole. Furthermore, chancellor 厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 SPD played a central role in the political miscalculations preceding the crisis. Even the EU's key axis of French-German cooperation appeared to suffer from the energy crisis's fallout, an impression both governments sought to counter by demonstrating their readiness for finding joint answers.听
Yet, in the first twelve months in office 厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 administration also accomplished several energy policy breakthroughs in its crisis response that a year earlier appeared elusive or even unthinkable. Despite losing its primary gas corridor, Nord Stream 1, after Russia turned off the tap in August, the country鈥檚 gas storages were filled 100 percent ahead of schedule. An attack that blew up the pipeline under the Baltic Sea in late September then made a recourse to the supply route all but impossible. Aside from the government rapidly securing new import venues and with Germany鈥檚 neighbours for natural gas, this had been made possible by businesses and households heeding government calls to reduce consumption. A rapid ramp-up of import infrastructure for liquefied natural gas (LNG), largely thought to be a dead duck when the traffic light coalition took over, have been pursued since February to further bolster long-term supply by 2023. The first floating import terminal could receive deliveries as early as December or January of next year.

Comeback of coal and extension for nuclear power a hard sell for Green voters
To secure the energy system from possible gas and electricity shortages in the interim, several coal-fired power plants have been brought back to supplement the country鈥檚 power system and replace gas-fired units. The decision to bring back coal has been a hard sell to members of the Green Party, but nevertheless was carried out swiftly after the war鈥檚 outbreak. Economy and climate minister Robert Habeck from the Green Party sought to calm critics of the coal return by striking a deal with western coal state North Rhine-Westphalia and energy company RWE. The idea was to stick to the 2030 end date for fossil fuel consumption in the state despite temporarily bringing capacity back online 鈥 a compromise that appears to be more difficult to achieve with eastern regions.
Another turnaround that unsettled the Green Party was the runtime extension for Germany鈥檚 remaining three nuclear plants, which took the government much longer to decide. It required chancellor Scholz to put his foot down to end a months-long dispute between Habeck and finance minister Christian Lindner, who had led calls for a long-term return to nuclear power. The plants will now get a three-month extension until April 2023 before going offline for good.
In his role as treasurer, Lindner, who as head of the pro-business FPD has often condemned high public spending, oversaw the launch of four major aid programmes to help citizens and companies deal with high energy prices, including a 200 billion euro 鈥渄efence shield鈥 that includes caps for consumer prices of gas and electricity. While this has failed to ease fears that households could be in for a rude awakening when greatly increased energy bills land in their mailboxes next year, the measures helped calm markets and provided reassurances that the government would commit to addressing social hardships and preserving the country鈥檚 economic foundations. This challenge would continue to dominate political debates in 2023, when the country is expected to enter into a recession, Habeck said.
While providing support to struggling citizens and businesses without creating incentives to use more fossil fuels has posed many technical challenges for the involved ministries, the trade union-affiliated Hans B枚ckler Foundation called the measures 鈥.鈥 However, industry representatives were less satisfied, particularly in regards to support payments for struggling gas importers. Economy minister Habeck鈥檚 reputation, which had grown during his first months in the role, took a hit when his plans to fund a special gas levy that would have further increased prices fell flat in a last-minute decision in early autumn. Companies like Uniper, the country鈥檚 largest gas importer, had to be put under state control to avoid a collapse of the import infrastructure.
To counter the possibility of de-industrialisation and economic decline as a result of high energy prices and industry transformation, the energy transition and Germany鈥檚 quest for climate neutrality by 2045 have emerged as the traffic light coalition鈥檚 main trump card. At the presentation of the coalition treaty, Scholz announced that by ramping up climate-friendly technologies and leaving fossil fuels behind, his government would launch 鈥the biggest industrial modernisation project in 聽more than 100 years.鈥 This goal has been amplified by the urgency to use renewables to bring down energy prices and become more independent in supply.
Ambitious renewable power package's effects likely to become visible only in next years
There is optimism that this change in circumstances could ultimately benefit the entire project, illustrated by finance minister Lindner's relabelling of renewables as 鈥freedom energies鈥 that serve a purpose beyond fighting climate change. At the same time, years of fierce debate over the cost of renewable power integration -- compared to seemingly less expensive fossil fuels -- were to a large degree silenced by the enormous toll European economies are now paying to cushion the worst effects of the energy crisis. Egged on by government support programmes for efficiency measures, citizens also responded by adapting their equipment and behaviour, sometimes even exceeding the government鈥檚 expectations. Installations of heat pumps and applications for energy-efficient building modernisation reached record levels in 2022 as customers sought to shield themselves from future fossil fuel price hikes or even supply cuts.
However, the central task to expand Germany鈥檚 renewable power capacity 鈥 as well as complementary grid and storage infrastructure 鈥 remains the biggest challenge 厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 government must tackle to meet its green transformation targets. Virtually all decarbonisation efforts, from heating to industry and transportation, hinge on renewable power to electrify sectors and produce green hydrogen. With what it called Germany鈥檚 鈥biggest energy policy reform in decades,鈥 the coalition鈥檚 鈥淓aster Package鈥 introduced in spring 2022 aimed to get a breakthrough in pushing the energy transition forward and elevating the rollout of wind and solar power 鈥渢o a completely new level.鈥 With the help of this package and other legislative changes, the government wants to double the country鈥檚 onshore wind capacity to 115 gigawatts (GW) by 2030, more than triple offshore wind capacity and add over 20 GW of solar PV installations annually to reach a total of 215 GW by the end of the decade.
When announcing these policy reforms, the economy and climate ministry cautiously added that any 鈥減hysical鈥 differences against which the government鈥檚 performance could be measured will only start to reveal itself within the following three years until 2025. According to economic research institute DIW, the in many areas. In order to reach the 2030 targets, 鈥済rowth must pick up very strongly in the next few years,鈥 it concluded.
Several obstacles still stand in the way of reaching a new level of clean power production, among which a major lack of more than 200,000 skilled workers and persistent bureaucratic hurdles dampen the prospects for a timely roll-out. While the government has sought , economy minister Habeck insists that the red tape which prevents the building of renewable power infrastructure to a large extent stems from state regulation. Implementing construction after the federal government provides legal groundwork particularly for wind power would then be a task for the country鈥檚 16 state governments, the Green minister insisted.
Party rivalries a looming risk for coalition's cohesion
Voter response to the traffic light coalition has been mixed, reflecting the turmoil the new administration found itself in. Each of the three parties had to accept difficult decisions following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, some of which they likely would not have had put up with without a war in Europe. A released in November revealed that merely 15 percent of respondents thought the coalition stands for climate action and sustainability -- a disappointing result especially for the Green Party, which is reflected in the increasingly problematic relationship they have with climate protesters who use acts of civil disobedience to further their cause. Yet, the Greens are the only party that was able to improve its standing in the polls following last year鈥檚 election throughout their first year in government.
厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 SPD lost the top position to the conservative alliance under CDU leader Friedrich Merz and the traffic light coalition no longer has a majority in polls just one year after it was established. The party鈥檚 leading role in expanding energy trading with Russia in the past 20 years and 厂肠丑辞濒锄鈥檚 initial hesitance to clearly communicate his support for resisting Russia's aggression 鈥 although according to another by public broadcaster ZDF, more than half of voters say the chancellor is doing a good job.
Popularity is sliding for Lindner鈥檚 pro-business FDP, who had been most wary of the partnership with the two more left-leaning coalition partners. Having lost the most voter approval both in relative and absolute terms, they are also the coalition party who had the biggest losses in the four state elections that took place in 2022. Doubts could be spurred within the party about its benefits from the arrangement. After his party failed to enter parliament in the election in the large northern state of Lower Saxony, FDP head Lindner the whole traffic light coalition had 鈥渓ost legitimacy.鈥
The judgement of SPD co-leader Lars Klingbeil, meanwhile, is less pessimistic. In an with tabloid Bild, he said the traffic light coalition鈥檚 performance after one year with multiple crises ranging from 鈥淧utin鈥檚 war, the energy crisis, inflation and the climate鈥 could be rated as 鈥渟atisfying,鈥 given the circumstances. Klingbeil urged the coalition to engage in less public disputes and stop debating which one has enforced their interests best. The government should instead 鈥済o back to the political culture of our coalition negotiations,鈥 the SPD leader argued. 鈥淭his means: we will work on this together.鈥