COP21 - Media on Germany and the Paris Climate Summit
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 15 Dec
鈥淐limate of disillusion鈥
German environment minister Barbara Hendricks did not manage to carry the enthusiasm from the Paris Summit to Berlin, writes Cerstin Gammelin in S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淭his was not due to the agreement in Paris, but due to the fact that not a single minister or party colleague saw the necessity to bolster up Hendricks, in order to translate the Paris euphoria into a new impetus for the stagnating national initiatives for climate protection鈥, writes Gammelin.
Read the article in German .
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 15 Dec
鈥淵esterday鈥檚 technology鈥
The Paris Summit sent the clear signal that fossil plants will have to be phased out, but it would be a disaster if the agreement leads to a renaissance of nuclear energy, writes Bj枚rn Finke in a commentary in S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淐oal, oil and gas will not have a future, but nuclear power is also yesterday鈥檚 technology,鈥 argues Finke. Any government toying with the idea of building new nuclear plants should consider the huge costs involved in their construction, and also look at Germany鈥檚 expensive struggle over how to decommission them, he wrote. 鈥淚f states bet on nuclear plants, they saddle themselves with enormous follow-up costs. Add to this the risk of something going wrong while operating the plants or at waste disposal.鈥
Read the article in German .
Read the 威力彩玩法 dossier on the challenges of Germany鈥檚 nuclear phase out here.
听
Spiegel Online, 15 Dec
鈥淕ermany鈥檚 double standards: Preaching climate protection but supporting coal鈥
It is becoming increasingly clear that Germany will miss its climate action targets for 2020, writes Horand Knaup on Spiegel Online. The government puts great hope in the revival of the European Emissions Trading system and in reducing emissions from the building and transport sector. But little of this ambition has actually born fruit, neither in the transport sector where cheap petrol will likely lead to increasing emissions nor in the building and agricultural sector, Knaup writes. Meanwhile, state owned banks are still supporting the financing of coal-fired power stations, Knaup says.
Read the article in German .
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 14 Dec
鈥淔or humanity鈥
The Paris treaty is a 鈥渢errific day for humanity鈥 and spells out clearly that the fossil era is coming to an end, writes Michael Bauchm眉ller in a commentary for S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淭he plans for a faraway future will already have an impact today鈥 the language of the Paris treaty is so clear, that the message to investors alone will lead to a fall in global greenhouse gas emissions.鈥 Germany now has no other option than to make a reliable plan for a coal exit. The Paris agreement also made clear that other countries will follow the example of the German Energiewende, writes Bauchm眉ller.
Find the comment in German (behind paywall) .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 14 Dec
鈥淟owest common denominator in Paris鈥
The treaty is nothing but the lowest common denominator and will not reduce emissions by a single tonne of CO2 in the short and medium term, writes Andreas Mihm in a commentary for Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. The problem is not a lack of ambition, but reliable mechanisms to make them become reality, according to Mihm. 鈥淭he celebrations of Paris鈥 will be followed by a massive hangover.鈥 Mihm argues the treaty 鈥渋s not enough to convince business that the age of coal, oil and gas will be over soon. But exactly this would be needed.鈥 Mihm writes that extending emissions trading systems would help the climate more than the Paris treaty.
Read the commentary in German .
听
ARD, 14 Dec
鈥淕ermany must exit coal鈥
Germany must exit coal fast and without yielding to industry, argues Mathias Werth in a commentary in public broadcaster ARD. 鈥淚t鈥檚 no longer a question of technology or energy balance, but only a problem of political will,鈥 argues Werth. 鈥淚t would be a disgrace for Germany not to make full use of this chance, to exit from coal and nuclear.鈥
听
Tagesspiegel, 14 Dec
鈥淲e manage the coal exit鈥
The Paris treaty in effect seals the global coal exit, writes Dagmar Dehmer in a commentary in Tagesspiegel. 鈥淭he age of renewable energies has begun 鈥 everywhere.鈥 Dehmer argues the agreement sends the decisive signal to investors the world over: 鈥淵our wealth will not grow if you invest it in coal, oil or gas.鈥
Read the commentary in German .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 10 Dec
鈥淐limate change has a social dimension in Germany, too鈥
An article by Claudia Hornberg, of the Health Sciences faculty at the University of Bielefeld in the FAZ looks at the health impacts of climate change in Germany. Climate change impacts in Germany tends to be seen in terms of the economy and environment, perhaps because the health impacts seem less severe than in other parts of the world, Hornberg writes. But even in Central Europe, rising temperature lead to longer pollen seasons and the spread of invasive species such as ticks that carry Lyme disease.
听
Spiegel Online, 09 Dec
鈥淗ow the Germans are negotiating a climate miracle鈥
The Paris climate summit could result in a global commitment to decarbonisation, writes Axel Bojanowski for Spiegel, but there is still resistance from the oil producing states and India, as well as Japan, which would prefer a goal of 鈥渃limate neutrality鈥. But Germany has long been laying the groundwork for a commitment to decarbonisation, not just with the G7 agreement earlier this year, but also by bringing Brazil on board, which broke with the idea that decarbonisation should only be a goal of developed economies. But there is still resistance even within the EU from Poland, and everything may still hang on whether Merkel can persuade the country鈥檚 new president.
See the article in German听.
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 09 Dec
鈥淥ne climate, two worlds鈥
German industry insists that an agreement in Paris must have common rules for both industrialised and emerging economies, writes Michael Bauchm眉ller in the S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淎ll participating countries must accept comparable commitments,鈥 the article quotes J眉rgen Kerkhoff, head of the German Steel Federation, adding that an agreement without China was 鈥渦nthinkable鈥. The Federation of German Industries has expressed similar views, Bauchm眉ller says.
Historically, a distinction has been made between those countries that have been responsible for high levels of emissions in the past, and poorer countries that are seen as requiring more leeway for development. But things have changed, Bauchm眉ller argues, with China now the largest emitter in the world, Brazil and South Africa major exporters and the Gulf states among the richest countries in the world. The issue of differentiation is likely to remain a sticking point to the end, Bauchm眉ller writes.
See the article in German听.
听
Handelsblatt, 09 Dec
"Paris talks, Opec decides"
While 195 states debate the future of global climate, the Opec has sealed its fate, because oil-exporting countries will produce as much crude as they can, writes Christian Rickens in a commentary for Handelsblatt. This will push prices down, increasing demand and CO2 emissions, argues Rickens. "There is a bitter irony in the concurrence of the climate summit and the Opec meeting. It shows us who really holds the lever that can influence the global climate. All debates about two-degree targets and decarbonisation fall on deaf ears compared with the power of markets." Rickens says changes of a few percent in the price of oil have more influence on the global climate than all lofty commitments.
Der Spiegel, 08 Dec
鈥淧aris Climate Summit: Restrict!鈥
Writing in Der Spiegel, David B枚cking says the threat of climate change requires less consumption - that we all fly less, use less heating and eat less meat. But politicians understandably won鈥檛 preach such a message or limit individual freedoms, which would be unpopular with voters. During the oil crisis in the 1970s, the German government restricted car use and today Germans are willing to undergo increased security checks because of the terrorist attacks in Paris. But climate change is seen as an abstract threat and easier to ignore. Some have argued that only authoritarian regimes have the power to stop climate change. Limiting our own consumption, B枚cking therefore argues, is a defence of democracy.
See the article in German .
听
Die Welt, 08 Dec
鈥淭ricks, emotion and bitter truths鈥
In an interview with Die Welt, J眉rgen Trittin, a former German environment minister and veteran of international climate negotiations, gives his view of the talks in Paris. Trittin told the paper Europe had lost its leading role in the negotiations to China and the US, who are now the key players. China is now investing more than in the development of renewables than the US and Europe combined, which Trittin said was itself a success of the German Enegiewende, which drastically brought down its cost. 鈥淚t is a historic achievement that German electricity consumers gave the world,鈥 he said.
Find the interview in German 听(behind a paywall).
听
Frankfurter Rundschau, 08 Dec
鈥淕uest of climate friends鈥
Writing in the Frankfurter Rundschau, Joachim Wille und Christian Mihatsch say that although Germany has no official role at the Paris Summit 鈥 because the EU negotiates as a single block 鈥 German officials have taken on important roles. State Secretary for the Environment Jochen Flasbarth has been mandated together with Gabon鈥檚 finance minister to find a solution on climate finance, while his boss, Environment Minister Barbara Hendricks, is working with her Finish counterpart to represent the EU on differentiation. Their success will partly be down to perceptions of Germany in the negotiations, which the writers say have been boosted by the huge volumes of free coffee being distributed at the German pavilion. Everyone likes to come by for a 鈥渃offee with the Germans鈥 the article says.
听
Handelsblatt, 07 Dec
鈥淪till up in the air鈥
There are still many hurdles to an agreement in Paris and there is a real danger of disappointment, writes Klaus Stratmann in a commentary for business daily Handelsblatt. Negotiators have still not managed to establish a continuous process for readjusting climate pledges, there is still a gap of a few billion dollars in the Green Climate Fund, and it remains unclear whether a treaty will pass US domestic politics. 鈥淪o it鈥檚 the same story as at every other climate summit: We will only know at the last second if the international community is serious about the fight against climate change.鈥
听
Der Spiegel, 07 Dec
"The Ex-Climate Chancellor"
Chancellor Angela Merkel's reputation as "climate chancellor" is being damaged internationally because of Germany's lack of success on cutting carbon emissions under her leadership, Horand Knaup and Gerald Traufetter write for the magazine Der Spiegel. While Merkel urges world leaders in Paris to work towards the decarbonisation of the global economy, Germany looks likely to miss its own 2020 reduction targets because Merkel鈥檚 government has been too lenient on industry players such as carmakers and the owners of coal-fired power plants, they write.
Read a factsheet on Germany鈥檚 climate goals here.
Find a 威力彩玩法 factsheet on Angela Merkel's career as "climate chancellor" here.
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 07 Dec
"States are liable for their sins"
The insurance scheme against damages caused by climate change being planned at the Paris summit is an elegant solution and a big step for industrialised countries to address the issue of liability, writes Michael Bauchm眉ller in a commentary in S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. But he says the catch is climate change itself: 鈥淭he larger the consequences, the more difficult they are to insure.鈥 Bauchm眉ller writes that the commitment by G7 countries comes just at the right time, because 鈥渢here will only be an agreement if both issues can be addressed: Help for the poorest and the battle against climate change.鈥
Read the article in German .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 07 Dec
鈥淎 market for the climate鈥
It鈥檚 almost guaranteed there will be an agreement at the end of the Paris summit, including a commitment to "decarbonisation" or "climate neutrality", but the crucial question is whether it will provide detailed and binding guidelines on how to get there, writes Andreas Mihm in a commentary for Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. He says emission trading systems like the EU鈥檚 should be developed and extended. The topic will not feature in an agreement, but it would be sufficient if China and Germany pushed emissions trading during their upcoming G20 presidencies, according to Mihm. 鈥淢erkel should make the overdue step to include further sectors in the trading system. It鈥檚 not enough if energy and industry get a CO2 price tag, but transport, agriculture and real estate don鈥檛.鈥
Mihm also says it is deplorable that the government missed the opportunity in Paris to stress that enormous advance payments by German consumers gave the world affordable wind and solar technologies.
听
New York Times, 04 Dec
鈥淕ermany may offer model for reining in fossil fuel use鈥
Germany鈥檚 Energiewende could offer other countries ideas for fulfilling their climate protection pledges after the COP21 climate summit, currently underway in Paris, writes Melissa Eddy in The New York Times. Germany 鈥渉as claimed some success in diversifying its energy sources and balancing economic growth with environmental concerns,鈥 the newspaper says. The feature goes on to describe how Germany has expanded renewable energy and some of the obstacles it still faces in the project.
Read the article in English
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 03 Dec
鈥淓xit the climate trap鈥
The RWE split is good news for the Paris Climate Summit, argues Michael Bauchm眉ller in S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淭he company is initiating the liquidation of its lignite business. This is the meaning of the announcement that the new renewables subsidiary is to get money from financial markets, but not the old business,鈥 writes Bauchm眉ller. 鈥淟ignite is being phased out, pulverised between climate protection and green power.鈥 He laments that this is not the case beyond Europe, as there are plans to build 2,000 additional coal-fired plants around the globe. Only a price on carbon will stop these plans turning into reality, Bauchm眉ller argues. 鈥淭his will artificially increase the price of coal. That is the language that investors understand. The world over.鈥
听
Der Tagesspiegel. 03 Dec
鈥淎mbition grows on the way鈥
International climate policy slowly makes the transition from knowledge to action, writes Dagmar Dehmer in a commentary in Tagesspiegel. 鈥淏ut even if the way is obvious: The fight between the old economy, which destroys the climate, and the new, which can stabilise it, is not yet decided.鈥 She says World Climate Summits are, above all, world economic forums. 鈥淓very country attempts to preserve its old and well-tried business model for as long as possible.鈥 Still, Paris might be a unique opportunity because of the large amount of goodwill present. 鈥淭he chances to establish a self-learning agreement are good. If the architecture is right, ambition can continue to grow.鈥
听
Bloomberg, 01 Dec
鈥淥n clean energy, the wind blows from Germany鈥
Germany's ambitious, painful and expensive Energiewende has helped spur the development of technology that may soon work for others without massive subsidies, writes Leonid Bershidsky in a column for Bloomberg. Despite problems, 鈥渋t鈥檚 clear now that the program has been a success and that as long as there is a well-defined goal and a determined effort to reach it, the necessary technology will present itself," writes Bershidsky. "The most heated arguments at the COP21 climate change conference in Paris, which got under way on Monday, will be about how to split the cost of reducing emissions among richer and poorer countries. Germans have already answered the question by unilaterally shouldering the energy transition burden.鈥
Read the column in English .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 01 Dec
鈥淢erkel鈥檚 heartfelt wish鈥
German environmentalists may criticise Merkel, saying she could move further and faster to decarbonise the economy, writes Andreas Mihm in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. 听But off the record, many do value her long-standing engagement for climate protection. 鈥淢erkel, as a 听measured policy manager, needs to weigh up what is politically realistic against what is desirable for climate policy,鈥 writes Mihm.
听
Die Welt, 01 Dec
鈥淥nly the market economy can stop climate change鈥
The UN's climate conference in Paris is being staged as if it were humanity鈥檚 fateful hour, but that is exaggerated and diplomatically inept, writes Daniel Wetzel in a commentary in Die Welt. COP21 is 鈥渘ot the huge, decisive final summit of international climate diplomacy. Paris will not decide about apocalypse or saving the planet, nor is it a new era of world history. Paris is only a stepping stone,鈥 he says. Wetzel writes that existing climate diplomacy cannot stop climate change, which would be more easily abolished by market forces. 鈥淭he solution to the climate problem might be to extend trading of emissions certificates to the entire globe if possible. This would reduce the role of politics to distributing a sufficiently scarce number of tradeable permits.鈥 After that, everything else could be left to market forces, argues Wetzel.
Read the commentary in German .
听
The Economist, 30 Nov
Germany's "unusually big mistakes"
Germany has become a world leader in green power, but also serves as a warning about what can go wrong, writes Joel Budd in an Economist Special Report on climate change. 鈥淕ermany has made unusually big mistakes. Handing out enormous long-term subsidies to solar farms was unwise; abolishing nuclear power so quickly is crazy,鈥 argues Budd. He says the country鈥檚 biggest error was 鈥渢o ignore the fact that wind and solar power impose costs on the entire energy system, which go up more than proportionately鈥 as more are added, writes Budd.
Read the article in English .
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 30 Nov
鈥淲hy this climate summit could become a success鈥
There are two main reasons the Paris climate summit has higher chances of success than the meeting in Copenhagen, writes Michael Bauchm眉ller in a commentary for S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. 鈥淔irstly, many states do no longer perceive an exit from coal, oil and gas as a necessary good-bye to growth and prosperity鈥 Secondly, for the first time, all states are prepared to do something against global warming.鈥 But there is one catch, because the agreement in sight is voluntary. So if things are really going well in Paris, we might see a deal to monitor progress every few years, writes Bauchm眉ller.
Read the editorial in German .
听
General-Anzeiger, 30 Nov
鈥淭he ultimatum鈥
The Paris summit is meant to secure livelihoods for a humanity that is approaching eight billion members but, surprisingly, the media and general public are only interested in it in passing, writes Wolfgang Wiedlich in a commentary in General Anzeiger. He laments that nobody has told society clearly what 鈥渄ecarbonisation鈥 by 2050 would mean in reality. 鈥淚f Paris would be really successful, the people would be astonished. To save the climate, more is needed than energy-saving lightbulbs and abstinence from strawberries in December.鈥
Find the commentary in German .
Potsdam Institute for Climate Imapact Research, 27 Nov
鈥淧rice on CO2: Why finance ministers could save the climate鈥
Finance ministers around the world should have an interest in putting a price on carbon, irrespective of the risks of unabated climate change, a study by scientists at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK) finds. Governments would benefit from charging for CO2 emissions while lowering taxes on capital and work. Revenue from the CO2 price could be used on schools, infrastructure and security, the researcher suggest.
Find the PIK study in English (behind pay-wall).
听
Huffington Post, 26 Nov
鈥淐limate protection: A transatlantic reason for optimism鈥
Peter Wittig, the German Ambassador to the US, writes in a commentary for the Huffington Post that he is optimistic the Paris Climate Conference will yield positive results.听 He says there is unprecedented transatlantic unity on the issue of climate change, green energy is becoming affordable, and there are many pledges from the public and private sectors. Wittig explains that the Energiewende is a concrete policy to shift away from fossil fuels and nuclear energy, and fits well with the EU鈥檚 ambitious energy and climate policy. He argues Germany鈥檚 energy transition protects the environment, makes economic sense, and is making the country more independent, as well as providing geopolitical security.
Read his commentary in English .
听
Energy-Intensive Industries in Germany (EID), 26 Nov
鈥淲e need a level playing field鈥
The Association of Energy-Intensive Industries in Germany (EID) says it is in favour of an ambitious climate agreement in Paris, but insists European industries will need support to maintain its competitiveness.听 The climate summit was likely to produce a deal pointing in the right direction of more global climate action, but Europe looked still likely to pursue more ambitious goals than the rest of the world, Utz Tillmann, EID spokesman and head of the German Chemicals Industry Association VCI, told journalists. The EU commission's planned reforms of the European emissions trading system posed a risk to many energy intensive industries and needed to be corrected in order to avoid "carbon leakage", i.e. the move of energy and carbon intensive industries abroad.
Read the EID press release in German .
听
IPG Journal, 24 Nov
鈥淚t鈥檚 our duty鈥
A Paris climate agreement has to make clear that a maximum of 2掳C warming is all that the world鈥檚 nations will permit to happen, writes Germany鈥檚 environment minister Barbara Hendricks in a guest article for IPG Journal on international policy and society. 鈥淢oreover, we need a global long-term target that sends a clear signal to economy and society: The age of fossil fuels is approaching its end. We need a 鈥榞reen zero鈥, that鈥檚 zero CO2 emissions from fossil fuels in the course of this century,鈥 Hendricks writes. The fact that people are becoming impoverished because wealthy countries in particular were not showing consideration for the ecological boundaries of the world, was first and foremost an ethical problem. 鈥淚f we want to prevent the reasons for migration and flight, we need to seriously address climate change.鈥
Read the article in German .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine, 23 Nov
鈥淐limate target threatens steel workers鈥
The Paris climate summit must create uniform and binding environmental standards on a global scale so energy-intensive industries are not forced out of Europe by ambitious climate policies, argues Wolfgang Eder, CEO of Austrian steel company Voestalpine and president of the , in a commentary in Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. A Paris agreement with nothing more than voluntary pledges would be a lazy compromise and a provocation for all observers, according to Eder. 鈥淪hould Europe insist on its single-sided leading role, even though it is not even responsible for ten percent of global CO2 emissions, this would have unforeseeable long-term consequences for prosperity, social standards and political peace,鈥 writes Eder. 鈥淭he refugee crisis and the restructuring of Europe as a financial centre pose enough challenges.鈥
听
Tagesspiegel, 20 Nov
鈥淲e have to change our way of life!鈥
In order to achieve more climate protection and the 鈥渆cologic conversion鈥 Pope Francis has called for, not only politicians have to act, but every one of us, writes Franz-Josef Overbeck, Catholic bishop of the Essen diocese, in an opinion piece for the Tagesspiegel. Hopes and expectations for the Paris climate summit are high, he says. According to the pope, lifestyle changes could amount to more than just small individual contributions to protecting the environment by putting pressure on those with political and economic power.听
Read the op-ed in German .
听
Handelsblatt, 18 Nov
鈥淕reen capital鈥
While politicians argue about climate protection, the market is making companies more important actors than nation states in the fight against global warming, argues Hans-J眉rgen Jakobs in a commentary for business daily Handelsblatt. 鈥淐ompanies are betting increasingly on the yield of green investments and saying good-bye to fossil energies, because they fear consequential costs,鈥 writes Jakobs. 鈥淚n a nutshell: After they were ignored for years, 鈥榚xternal costs鈥 are coming into the calculation.鈥 Jakobs argues it is not a question of capitalism versus climate protection. To the contrary, it is market forces like the sharp drop in renewables prices and 鈥榞reen money鈥, looking far beyond the nearest election, that stir hope in the fight against global warming.
Find the article in German (behind paywall) .
听
Handelsblatt, 17 Nov
鈥淭here is no political will鈥
In an interview with Handelsblatt, Greenpeace director Kumi Naidoo says he has low expectations for the Paris climate conference because there is a lack of political will to exit from fossil fuels. He told the paper that while the Energiewende has provided inspiration, there is a contradiction between what Merkel says internationally and the reality in Germany. 鈥淢erkel has without doubt negotiated hard to make Paris a success,鈥 he told the paper. 鈥淏ut in Germany itself, CO2 emissions are stagnating, because the chancellor has delayed the exit from coal.鈥
See the interview in German .
听
German Association of Energy and Water Industries (BDEW), 13 Nov
鈥淐limate action needs clear financial commitment鈥
The BDEW听has citicised the decision by the European finance ministers not to make concrete commitments for climate finance in developing countries. 鈥淐limate action can only work globally. With a view to the upcoming climate summit in Paris, the European Union should act as a good example and make binding commitments on financing the climate funds [鈥,鈥 BDEW head Hildegard M眉ller said in a press release. The BDEW stood by its target of achieving a carbon-neutral energy supply in Europe by 2050.
Read the press release in German .
Read a Climate Home article on the EU finance minister鈥檚 decision in English .
听
The United Nations Global Compact-Accenture CEO Study, 13 Nov
鈥淪pecial Edition: A Call to Climate Action鈥
The majority of business leaders around the world are in favour of a long-term climate agreement to be decided in Paris in December, calling it critical to supporting private sector investment in low-carbon solutions, according to a study by the United Nations Global Compact and Accenture. Siemens CEO Joe Kaeser says in the study: "The opportunity is clear: We have the technologies, we have the business cases, and we have the responsibility. Now all we need is the commitment". Kurt Bock, CEO at German chemicals company BASF said: 鈥淎t COP21, politicians have the chance to set up a long-term, reliable emission reduction framework, enabled by low-carbon technologies... Creative minds in business all over the world would have a clear picture of the low-carbon future they are innovating for, finding answers to the substantial challenges we are facing.鈥
Find the survey in English .
听
International Energy Agency (IEA), 10 Nov
World Energy Outlook 2015
The IEA has published its World Energy Outlook 2015. In advance of the UN climate summit in Paris, 鈥渢here are clear signs that an energy transition is underway: renewables contributed almost half of the world's new power generation capacity in 2014 and have already become the second-largest source of electricity (after coal),鈥 the report finds. Global energy demand should grow by nearly one-third by 2040, the agency found. However, the link between economic growth and energy-related emissions should weaken.
Read an executive summary of the report in English .
听
Bild Online, 10 Nov
鈥3.5 million Germans endangered by sea-level rise鈥
If the temperature rises by 4掳 Celsius, 3.5 million people on Germany鈥檚 coasts would be endangered by rising sea levels; if the temperature increases by 2掳 Celsius, 1.3 million people would be at risk, mass tabloid Bild reports. China and coastal cities like New York, London and Mumbai would be even worse hit.
Read the article in German .
听
Handelsblatt/Germanwatch, 10 Nov
鈥淐limate change destroys prosperity鈥
According to a study by NGO Germanwatch, the economic damages of climate change far outweigh the costs of ambitious policies to prevent it, reports the Handelsblatt. The study estimates economic gains from climate protection will add up to 16 trillion euros by 2050, writes Silke Kersting. This compares to IPCC calculations showing that ambitious climate protection would require investments of about five trillion euros. 鈥淎 less-ambitious climate policy destroys future prosperity,鈥 said Germanwatch policy director Christoph Bals.
Read the article in German in Handelsblatt .
Find the Germanwatch press release in German .
听
AFP, 09 Nov
鈥淏arbara Hendricks calls for recognition of climate refugees鈥
German environment minister Barbara Hendricks says the UN should allow for a new category of climate refugees, AFP reports. Without an effective climate policy, drought and flooding would destabilise states, forcing people to flee, she said in an interview. Many climate refugees who had already lost their livelihoods due to global warming were currently discredited as economic migrants, the minister said. Hendricks wants industrial nations to take responsibility for this issue, because, she says, the industrialisation of developed countries has caused and is still causing global pollution.
Read the report in German .
听
Die Tageszeitung - taz, 09 Nov
鈥淐limate action, born in the U.S.A.鈥
We have to cast off the misconception that climate action is a German invention and that the US doesn鈥檛 care about it, says Bernhard P枚tter in an opinion piece for taz. President Obama has set new standards by rejecting the Keystone XL pipeline. Meanwhile Germany has just decided to give subsidies to redundant brown coal plants, P枚tter says. Three weeks before the UN climate conference in Paris, Germany鈥檚 鈥渃limate chancellor鈥 Angela Merkel should take Obama as an example.
听
PewResearchCenter, 06 Nov
87 percent of Germans in favour of national CO2 cuts as part of international climate agreement
55 percent of German citizens regard climate change as a 鈥渧ery serious problem鈥, American think-tank Pew found. The global median is 54 percent, in the US the figure is 45 percent, in the UK 41 percent, in Poland 19 percent, in China 18 percent and in Russia 33 percent. Interviewing over 45,000 people in 40 countries, the researchers found that globally 78 percent of people support an international agreement limiting greenhouse gas emissions; in Germany it was 87 percent and in China 71 percent.
Find the full Pew report in English .
听
Der Spiegel, 02 Nov
Climate expert Schellnhuber wonders after summits: Is there intelligent life on earth?
Hans Joachim Schellnhuber, physicist and head of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK), admits that on bad days he gets depressed thinking about the climate summit in Paris, he told Der Spiegel in an interview. But at other times he believed 鈥渨e can do this鈥. 听鈥淚t will definitely be a tight race for human kind,鈥 Schellnhuber said. But he saw a glimmer of hope when looking at the climate change projections of his institute which, for the first time after pledges by China and India, showed a warming of 2.7掳C by the end of the century. In a , Schellnhuber still puts the likelihood that humans will limit global warming at below 20 percent, citing his 鈥淜afkaesque鈥 experiences with climate summits. One leaves them 鈥渨ith the question whether there is intelligent life on earth鈥, he said.
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 02 Nov
鈥淪ign of Hope鈥
A global warming of 2.7掳C by the end of this century will gravely affect livelihoods around the world, writes Andreas Mihm in a commentary for Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. And temperatures might rise further as it is unclear how realistic the UN forecast is, he warns. 鈥淚t would be careless to rely on great air polluter China to reduce emissions a few years before the target date 2030,鈥 argues Mihm. 鈥淏ut however critical the evaluation of this insufficient collection of announcements - it also shows that the subject is taken seriously around the globe. That is a sign of hope.鈥
The UN said last week that the combined impact of the Intended Nationally Determined Contributions (INDCs) are capable of limiting the rise in temperature to around 2.7掳C by the end of the century.
Find a text on the UN climate forecast here.
UN Climate Change Secretariat / NGOs, 30 Oct
鈥淕lobal response to climate change keeps door open to 2 degree C temperature limit鈥
A report assessing the 140 climate action plans submitted to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) ahead of the Paris summit shows that combined effort can help curb damaging greenhouse gases, the UN says in a press release. The combined impact of the Intended Nationally Determined Contributions (INDCs) 鈥渨ill lead to a fall in per capita emissions over the coming 15 years鈥, the report finds. Furthermore, emissions will fall by as much as 8 percent in 2025 and 9 percent in 2030, and are capable of limiting the forecast temperature to a rise of around 2.7 degrees Celsius by the end of the century. Although this does not meet the 2-degree limit scientists recommend, it is lower than the 4-5 degree Celsius rise many had previously predicted, says UNFCCC Executive Secretary Christiana Figueres. Germany鈥檚 environment state secretary Jochen Flasbarth said that the long term goal had to be decarbonisation by the end of the century.
Separately, NGOs Germanwatch and Bread for the World jointly commented on the findings. They said that the direction was good but insisted that more effort was needed. 鈥淥n the one hand, the Paris climate has achieved something significant: the self-established goals of around 150 countries are on the table. On the other hand, it is clear that these contributions are not enough to prevent dangerous climate change,鈥 said S枚nke Kreft, team leader of international climate policy at Germanwatch. Read
WWF Germany said that a mechanism which forces individual states to reduce emissions every five years would have to be decided in Paris. 鈥淚t鈥檚 necessary that fossil energies like coal, oil and gas will be phased-out faster and in a more sustainable way than currently envisaged in Paris,鈥 Regine G眉nther, WWF head of climate and energy policy, said. Read
Read the UNFCCC press release in English .
Read the full UNFCCC report .
听
WirtschaftsWoche, 23 Oct
鈥淐limate summit in Paris will not result in joint obligations鈥
The history of climate negotiations shows that handing in climate action plans is one thing - but abiding by them is a different story, German economist Axel Ockenfels, from the University of Cologne, told the WirtschaftsWoche. 鈥淧aris won鈥檛 slow down climate change considerably and it won鈥檛 result in a joint obligation,鈥 he said. Ockenfels suggests that states should negotiate about a global price on CO2 emissions. Such a price would disadvantage no one and governments could invest the generated revenue in lowering other costs.
Read the article in German .
听
听SWR2, 23 Oct
鈥淗endricks: 鈥楤ring on Paris鈥欌
The climate agreement of Paris will not be the finishing point, Germany鈥檚 Environment Minister Barbara Hendricks told SWR2 in an interview. But it was important that some decisions in it are binding, such as the 2掳C warming limit for the end of the century and how CO2 emissions are measured, she said. Every country also had to become more and more ambitious in their climate targets, she added.
Listen to the interview in German .
听
Potsdam Institute for Climate Research, 23 Oct
鈥淣ational contributions provide entry point for the low-carbon transformation鈥
Commitments to reduce emissions so far submitted by countries ahead of COP21 fall short of keeping global warming below 2掳C, according to a report published by a consortium of 14 research institutes, including the Potsdam Institute for Climate Research (PIK). But they do 鈥渋mply an unprecedented acceleration and consolidation of action against climate change in major economies around the world鈥 and 鈥渃an serve as an entry point for the deep low-carbon transformation鈥. PIK said the success of the agreement would depend on a mechanism to strengthen commitments by 2020.
See the press release in English .
听
Handelsblatt, 21 Oct
鈥淕rown up climate politics鈥
We are seeing a paradigm shift in climate negotiations 23 years after the UN framework convention on climate change was adopted, writes , researcher at the Stiftung Wissenschaft and Politik (SWP) in a guest article for the Handelsblatt. The focus has moved from 鈥渞escuing the world climate鈥 to negotiating politically and economically viable measures, he says. The new priority is to integrate all states into a climate treaty, rather than to come up with the most ambitious treaty that insists on emission reductions to ensure the 2掳C warming limit. Because with the latter, Europeans would end up alone - just as they did with the Kyoto-protocol.
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 19 Oct
鈥淐ursed oil鈥
As a last preparatory meeting ahead of the global climate summit in Paris gets underway in Bonn this week, environmental activists fear that cheap oil could limit the pressure on negotiators to agree on ambitious climate targets, writes Michael Bauchm眉ller in the S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. A low oil price could mean increased use of fuel in the transport sector and less incentive to increase energy efficiency in the building sector. But so far, at least in Germany, oil consumption for transport and heating is falling despite the low price, and home insulation schemes have experienced only a slight loss of interest, Bauchm眉ller writes.
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 14 Oct
鈥淥il鈥檚 closing sale鈥
The global movement to divest from fossil fuels has gathered rapid support this year and has turned 鈥減eak oil鈥 arguments upside-down, writes Marcus Theurer in a commentary for the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. 听鈥淭he closing sale might start long before the age of oil comes to an end," because oil-producing countries might step up production for fear the market could disappear altogether. 鈥淭he climate debate will radically alter the rules of the oil industry and question companies鈥 business models,鈥 writes Theurer. He says this will not happen from one day to the next, but it won鈥檛 take as long as oil managers claim.
听
Handelsblatt, 13 Oct
鈥淚n a trap鈥
The vision of a global agreement to limit CO2 emissions at the UN Paris Climate Summit (COP21) is threatened by continued subsidies for fossil-based energy sources, writes Klaus Stratmann in a commentary in the Handelsblatt. 鈥淭he failure of the international community to act is dangerously intersected with a wave of investments in climate-damaging coal power plants, especially in energy hungry emerging countries,鈥 he says. These countries are subsidising coal, gas and above all oil with hundreds of billions of dollars, he says, and little has changed in this area in the last five or ten years.听 Even worse, he points out, is that very little of this money trickles down to needy citizens of those countries. 鈥淭hus subsidies for fossil energy sources burden the CO2 accounts and above all the budgets of these countries,鈥 he says. 鈥淚t would be better to invest this money in climate-friendly technology.鈥
听听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 13 Oct
鈥淓U says goodbye to binding climate goals鈥
According to a ten-page paper obtained by the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, the European Union is abandoning its plans for setting long-term climate goals for expanding renewable energy shares in the power mix and increasing energy efficiency. Concrete steps, such as how countries will increase the share of wind and solar energy by 2030, should be taken in national action plans, the newspaper writes. These plans can be adjusted at any time, however, if national conditions change, according to the paper. Germany had wanted to achieve binding targets for these currently unbinding goals, the newspaper says, but this was a step too far for many 鈥 besides Eastern European countries, also France and the UK were against this idea, the FAZ cites diplomatic sources as saying. In autumn 2014, heads of government agreed to raise the share of renewables to 27% of consumption and to increase energy efficiency by 27%, the FAZ says
Read a 威力彩玩法 factsheet about Germany's emissions targets here.
听
Handelsblatt, 13 Oct
鈥淭he principle of the alms bowl鈥
In an interview with the Handelsblatt, Ottmar Edenhofer, chief economist of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, says asking countries to contribute what they can to reducing CO2 emissions is like begging for money.听 This is 鈥渢he principle of the alms bowl,鈥 he says, adding that 听an agreement to keep the world from warming by more than 2 degrees Celsius by the end of the century is unlikely at the summit.听 Despite the fact that most countries recognise the necessity to do so, they do not see the necessity for global cooperation, he says.听 The summit could have some successes, however, he says. For example, if countries manage to find a way to put a price on CO2. 鈥淯ntil now, one tonne of CO2 is being subsidised on average with 150 dollars. It鈥檚 no wonder that many countries are still depending on coal,鈥 he says. Europe could start with its emissions trading scheme, which needs reform, he says. 鈥淚n order for there to be an effect, we need a minimum price for CO2; 20 euros and upwards is imaginable. But the market stability reserve that the EU has agreed to is not helpful,鈥 he says.听 鈥淚t is unrealistic to expect that CO2 emissions will fall without a reasonable price.鈥
Read the interview in German (behind a paywall) .
听
Frankfurter Rundschau, 08 Oct
鈥淎n ambitious climate programme for India鈥
Germany has agreed to finance India鈥檚 roll out of solar energy with two billion euros and the subcontinent has finally made its climate targets public, writes Brigitte Knopf, secretary general of the Mercator Research Institute on Global Commons and Climate Change, in an opinion piece in the Frankfurter Rundschau. 鈥淭he fact that countries like India, who justly perceived themselves not as part of the problem, now want to become part of a solution, inspires hope that the international climate negotiations in Paris can be a success,鈥 writes Knopf. But even if the intended nationally determined contributions (INDCs) become reality, the world would still be on track to a warming of 2.7 degrees celsius; and at present, 3.6 degrees seem more likely. To avoid this fate, CO2 heavyweights like India need an ambitious climate programme and not just good intentions, writes Knopf. 鈥淭he INDCs must not become empty promises. Compliance with voluntary announcements to cut CO2 must be verified鈥hese rules for transparency must become part of an agreement in Paris.鈥澨
听
klimaretter.info, 01. Oct
鈥淭he world on a 3.5-degree path鈥
October 1 is the deadline for countries to hand in their climate protection goals to the UN climate secretary in Bonn, and few have come up with plans that will keep the earth鈥檚 temperature from rising by more than 2 degrees celsius this century, reports Benjamin von Brackel in Klimaretter.info.听 The goals are the basis for the UN Climate Summit in December, when countries will commit themselves to keeping emissions below certain levels. Climate analysts from Climate Interactive in Washington, DC, calculate on the basis of 72 countries鈥 current pledges that temperatures will rise by 3.5 degrees, the author says. Of the major polluters, only India has not yet turned in its plans, insisting that industrial countries first have to cut their greenhouse gases and the emerging countries must focus on eradicating poverty, the author writes. However, India still plans to turn in a plan, but one day after the deadline. The question then is whether the targets are enough to keep global warming down to 2 degrees celsius in order to keep the climate system stable.
Read the article in German.
听
Handelsblatt, 01 Oct
鈥淐limate protection poses problems for industry鈥
German and Austrian energy intensive companies are worried about the negative effects of more stringent climate protection rules, which could threaten their businesses and hundreds of thousands of jobs, according to a study by the Handelsblatt Research Institute, writes Martin Wocher in the Handelsblatt. Even though no such shutdowns or shifting of operations abroad have occurred yet, this could happen gradually, the institute concludes. Under particular threat is the steel industry, in light of EU plans to remove 1.5 billion CO2 certificates from the market as of 2019. Companies think this could cause the price to rise sharply to around 鈧30 per tonne of CO2 from 鈧7 now, according to the article. Because of exemptions or excess certificates on the market, companies have until now paid little or nothing for the right to pollute, according to the article. This could change dramatically, bringing costs of a billion euros a year for steel companies in Germany alone, the article says.
Read a dossier on competitiveness and the Energiewende here.
听
Handelsblatt, 01 Oct
鈥淲e need to accept the obstacles鈥
Germany鈥檚 environment minister Barbara Hendricks is very confident that governments will agree to a way of limiting greenhouse gas emissions in order to keep global warming under 2掳C at the UN conference in Paris, she said during an interview with Handelsblatt. This is even if not all countries would sign a legally-binding climate treaty. Another central target of the negotiations was to agree on binding measuring and monitoring methods, Hendricks said. And it would be very important for a successful outcome in Paris that industrial nations kept their promises to finance climate change mitigation and adaptation in developing countries.
Read the interview in German (behind pay wall) .
听
S眉ddeutsche Zeitung, 28 Sept
鈥淎nd they are moving after all鈥
War, terror, climate change 鈥 for a long time it looked as if the United Nations was getting nowhere, writes Stefan Ulrich in the S眉ddeutsche Zeitung. But as China announces an ambitious environment programme, including an emissions trading scheme, things might be moving after all, he says. China鈥檚 president Xi Jinping has apparently stopped depicting China as a developing country in order to block climate action. In addition, Chancellor Angela Merkel and the Pope are calling on the heads of states and governments to commit to climate action ahead of Paris, Ulrich writes.
听
Tagesspiegel, 28 Sept
鈥淯nited for a better world鈥
Chancellor Angela Merkel was probably watched even more closely than the Pope at the UN sustainability conference in New York, write Dagmar Dehmer and Barbara Junge in the Tagesspiegel. The spotlight was on her not only because of VW but also because of the energy transition, which is followed closely around the world, sometimes with enthusiasm, sometimes with 鈥渂listering rejection鈥. Merkel promised to increase Germany鈥檚 development budget to 0.7 percent of the GDP and reminded industrialised nations about their promise to pay 100 billion dollars into a green climate fund. However, her remarks about who will contribute this money remained vague, as she spoke about a joint responsibility of private and state funding, the authors say.
Read the article in German .
听
International New York Times, 25 Sept
鈥淕ermans take a tumble from moral high ground鈥
鈥淰olkswagen鈥檚 deception raises doubt in a nation known for following rules,鈥 writes Alison Smale in the International New York Times. It also puts the nation in 鈥渁n awkward spot鈥 ahead of the UN climate change summit in Paris in December, where Germany would be held up as a model for how an industrial nation can replace fossil fuels largely with renewables, the author says.
听
Bloomberg, 24 Sept
鈥淢erkel鈥檚 climate crusading risks being blemished by VW 蝉肠补苍诲补濒鈥
The Volkswagen emissions-cheating scandal could sully Germany鈥檚 reputation as a model for climate protection, just as Chancellor Angela Merkel heads to New York this weekend to push for environmental responsibility, writes Patrick Donahue for BloombergBusiness. Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer, director of the Center for Automotive Research at the University of Duisberg-Essen, says Merkel鈥檚 government has not done enough to push the powerful automotive industry to greener technology like electric cars, according to the article.
Read the BloombergBusiness article in English .
听
Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung, 21 Sept
鈥淲orried about the climate鈥
The very hot and dry summer of 2015 was a sign of climate change, 46 percent of Germans believe. In contrast, 40 percent told pollster Institut f眉r Demoskopie Allensbach that they believe the high temperatures were a normal weather phenomenon.